Podcast Episode 26: Sincerity and Artifice in Realism


England and France

By the middle of the nineteenth century, Realism was an international movement. In England, the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood were the rebellious Realists, challenging the classicism of the Academy. The English artists worked in natural light and celebrated the narrative in visual art. The PRB quickly found support though the art critic John Ruskin and began to focus on modern problems in the modern world. It is this penchant for the literary and this British interest in urban contemporary life that separates the Pre-Raphaelite Movement from the Realism across the Channel.

Realism in France was a fragmented movement. On one hand there were the so-called “official Realists,” or those who pleased the government, and on the other hand there were the avant-garde Realists. However within the group of artist who challenged the Academy standards, there was a philosophical split—is art a reflection of reality and therefore capable of being “sincere,” or is art in and of itself “artificial” and therefore is a cynical artifice? Within this aesthetic question is the differing political stances, with sincerity as being more politically active and artifice as being more of a social commentary. In France, “realism” divided along two poles, “sincerity,” as with Millet and Courbet, or “artifice,” as with Manet.

Also listen to “Realism in Europe, Part Two” and “Realism in Europe, Part One”

Read “Avant-Garde Realism inFrance” and “Realism and the Role of the Realist Artist”

and “Realism and Naturalism in Art” and “Salon Realism in France”

and “Realism and Naturalism in Art” and Avant-Garde Realism in England”

and “The Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood”



If you have found this material useful, please give credit to
Dr. Jeanne S. M. Willette and Art History Unstuffed.

Thank you.
[email protected]

Important Announcement

The Podcasts from this Website

by Dr. Jeanne S. M. Willette

are now available through iTunes and can be listened to on your iPad

Art History Unstuffed: The Podcasts

Also the complete

Art History Timeline Videos

by Dr. Jeanne S. M. Willette

are now available and can be viewed on You Tube

This twenty-seven episode series of five minute videos span Western art history, from the Caves to Romanticism. The videos can be used by students and teachers as introductory, supplementary or review material. Each video is written,narrated and produced by the author of this website, and is reinforced by written text and is richly illustrated by many images. The entire Timeline can be accessed through

this link: Art History Timeline


  1. […] and “Sincerity and Artifice in French Realism” […]